FantasyHQFantasyHQ

James Cook vs DeVonta Smith: Who Wins the Dynasty Trade?

FormatDynasty · Superflex (2QB) · Half-PPR — FantasyHQ multi-source consensus.
James Cook
James Cook
BUF · RB6 · Age 27
Worth more
6,712dynasty value
FHQ score84.4/100
SignalHOLD
Positional rankRB6
VS
DeVonta Smith
DeVonta Smith
CAR · WR18 · Age 23 · Rookie
5,300dynasty value
FHQ score70.3/100
SignalHOLD
Positional rankWR18

The verdict: James Cook wins

James Cook is the clear winner over DeVonta Smith — a 21% value gap (6,712 vs 5,300) in Superflex dynasty.

⚖️ Not a fair 1-for-1 — the DeVonta Smith side needs a sweetener (a mid pick or depth piece) to even it out.
⚖️ Grade this exact trade in TradeHQ James profile DeVonta profile

Should you trade James Cook for DeVonta Smith?

James Cook carries a FantasyHQ Superflex dynasty value of 6,712 (RB6, current signal HOLD), while DeVonta Smith sits at 5,300 (WR18, HOLD). Not a fair 1-for-1 — the DeVonta Smith side needs a sweetener (a mid pick or depth piece) to even it out. Values are multi-source consensus for 12-team Superflex dynasty; switch to your exact league settings in TradeHQ to grade the real deal.

More James comparisons

More DeVonta comparisons

© FantasyHQ · Multi-source consensus dynasty values Home · Players · Trade Calculator